Questions remain post-election: From Poilevre’s MP seat loss to Alberta’s separation rhetoric legality

Another federal election is behind us, as the Liberals will lead the country with a minority government.

University of Lethbridge Department of Political Science Professor Dr. Yale Belanger notes participation at the polls was up from 2021 with 68.7 per cent in Canada.

Even though a majority of Alberta ridings voted Conservative in this week’s federal election, what happens now with Conservative leader Pierre Poilevre losing his seat as a Member of Parliament?

Belanger says Poilevre appears to have support post-election, as potential replacements circulate. “If he retains support following a mandatory leadership review, he will likely trigger a by-election in another riding, provided a sitting MP willingly steps down.”

There is a legal requirement for a political party leader to hold a Parliamentary seat, Belanger explains. Another MP can continue to lead the party and handle media, strategy and internal leadership duties from outside the House of Commons, until a by-election is held.

In Alberta, 63.5 per cent voted Conservative, 27.9 per cent voted Liberal and 6.3 per cent voted NDP.

With Alberta Premier Danielle Smith’s recent rhetoric about the province’s separation, and depending on the polls and who you ask, 10-25 per cent of Albertans have indicated a desire to discuss separation, adds Belanger. “The number of people who voted Liberal/NDP is double that of those who are pressing for separation.”

Belanger says the Bloc dropped from 35 to 22 seats in Parliament, as Bloc Leader Yves-François Blanchet has noted Canadians want stability in Parliament and he will work with the incoming government in the short term. “The NDP is currently leaderless, suggesting it will also work closely with the Liberals to help regain equilibrium and momentum.”

According to Belanger, Mark Carney is a bridge builder, but his success will largely depend on whether the Official Opposition, the Bloc and the NDP will choose to oppose for the sake of opposing or work together. “To combat the Donald Trump threat by creating new domestic and international economic measures.”

Premier Smith, Belanger notes, is a political opportunist, “closely aligned with the more vocal elements of her UCP base.”

“Much of her current agenda seems driven by a desire to maintain power, rather than long-term policy goals. Criticizing Ottawa remains an easy and reliable tactic that consistently fuels regional resentment,” Belanger says. “I’d argue she is seeking to distract from the multiple scandals plaguing her government.”

Separation, Belanger adds, is not just a political question, but a legal, constitutional and moral one. “With Indigenous treaties being a central, non-negotiable part of the puzzle. It’s also improbable.”

“However, if we reach that stage, a province cannot unilaterally override or dissolve Treaty relationships, especially since they’re constitutionally protected,” Belanger explains. “Separation needs to be negotiated, which would demand First Nations’ consent, hence their participation.”

Nikki Ritchot
Nikki Ritchot
Nikki joined The Ranch 106.5 team as a news reporter in September of 2023. In addition to her news reports, you can occasionally hear her live filling in for the Big JD on the Trading Post. Nikki and her family moved to Vegreville in 2022, where she, her husband Jeff Dyck, and son Gabriel bought their very first house. Nikki really loves fall and multiple daily trips to Tim Hortons.

Continue Reading

ckvg Now playing play

- Advertisement -

Related Articles

- Advertisement -

Latest News

Rangers Fall In Home Opener

The Vegreville Rangers fought hard in Saturday's home opener but came up just short against St. Paul.

Eyes on the road: Tips for safe holiday travel as snow in forecast for parts of Alberta

Many parts of Alberta were under a special weather statement by Environment and Climate Change Canada as of Thursday morning.  

Alberta RCMP encourages safe driving to reduce collisions, fatalities this holiday weekend

Over the Thanksgiving long weekend, the Alberta RCMP will be conducting enhanced traffic enforcement aimed at reducing collisions, injuries, and fatalities on Alberta roads.

Maddigan Chrysler hosting food drive in support of the Vegreville Food Bank this month

Maddigan Chrysler is hosting a Food Drive in support of the Vegreville Food Bank this month.

Vegreville Rangers prepare for a busy weekend

A busy weekend for the Vegreville Rangers kicks off tomorrow night (Friday, October 9th). The team travels to Vermilion to battle the Tigers in NEAJBHL action.
- Advertisement -